Should the former colonial powers pay reparations to nations they once subjugated?



All you need to know about the world this 
week
SEE ALL ISSUES
EDITOR'S LETTER
Our world this week
FEATURE
The fall of the ‘caliphate’s’ capital
FEATURE
Why is the EU courting Europe’s ‘last dictator’?
FEATURE
The colossus of Beijing
FEATURE
HIV stigma: the beginning of the end?
www.aljazeera.com
Reclaiming Mosul's vibrant culture after ISIL
www.newyorker.com
The Danger of President Pence
www.bbc.co.uk
Kurz and charisma: What propels young leaders to power?
qz.com
Behind the scenes: How scientists decoded 2017's biggest discovery
foreignpolicy.com
Russia’s Neighbors Respond to Putin’s ‘Hybrid War’
roadsandkingdoms.com
Water, Water, Everywhere - Roads & Kingdoms
DEBATE
POLITICS
Should the former colonial powers pay reparations to nations they once subjugated? 12

The colonial era saw Europe’s share of the world’s GDP jump from 20% to 60%, leading many to point out that Europe didn’t develop the colonies - rather, the land, resources, and labour of the colonies developed Europe. Anthropologist Jason Hickel, writing in the Guardian, notes India commanded 27% of the world’s economy prior to British colonisation: when the colonialists left in 1947, it only represented 3%. Historian Mike Davis describes how the British overhauled India’s agricultural system, destroying traditional subsistence practices to make way for cash crops - at times exporting 10 million tonnes of food to Europe a year. As a result, up to 29 million Indians died of famine in the latter 19th century. Similarly, the socio-economic growth of Haiti - the first black nation to successfully rebel in 1804 against its coloniser, France - was instantly jeopardised by the colonial powers’ retaliatory boycott on Haitian products. France demanded 150 million francs as compensation; it took Haiti 122 years to pay. With many former colonies continuing to suffer from systemic poverty, widespread corruption, lack of infrastructure, and political instability, should the Western powers pay reparations? Opponents of this notion state that ex-colonies already receive their fair share of aid. Opponents also stress that the sins of the fathers should not be visited upon their children, and that those most likely to bear the financial brunt of eventual reparations won’t be the elites (whose present-day fortunes often derive from colonialism), but ordinary taxpayers. David Horowitz famously argued that reparations were a “separatist idea”, painting Africans as victims while pitting them against the nations which “gave them freedom”. Others suggest that compensation is impractical, politically unworkable, or divisive, focusing attention on the p

read more
Share Opinion
LATEST
LEADING
L
Add bio
contributions - pts
Submit
A journalistic initiative Sponsored by:
american-express-sponsor
About this
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website.
If you continue without changing your settings, we'll assume that you are happy to receive all cookies from this website.
OK